This last week has been an education for me.
I’ve always believed words were powerful — that’s why I love reading and talking about books — but it never once struck me how powerful my own words could be. That my own feelings and beliefs and thoughts, when strung together, could cause such a reaction. I never expected people within my own profession to look at what I said and simply react. To take the thoughts I had shared on this blog, read them, then put down their own thoughts to what I’d said.
Then spread them wildly.
I made the conscious choice to step back because I stood by what I’d said. It was, I believe, the first time I’ve written a post on a topic I was so passionate about and not had a second pair of eyes look over them. Every word came from my heart, came from a place of believing that everyone should have equal and equitable access to resources, knowledge.
To passion.
My words came back to me repeatedly and in ways that really hurt. That stomped upon my heart and my passion and my beliefs. That made a mockery out of me in a wide and downright painful way. I watched as a profession I went into because of how much it embraces sharing and knowledge choose to make light of an issue they didn’t understand. An issue that didn’t ignite them or make them feel like there has to be a better way.
I’m sitting in a weird place right now. I feel incredibly vulnerable and lost and sometimes question my own legitimacy and place in the world and regularly ask what the hell I am doing with my life. I read posts like this one — written by an incredibly impassioned 14-year-old — and then I read stories like this one in the New York Times, and they make me pause and think for a bit about where I am in the world. What it is that gets me going in the morning, what it is that makes me care about any and everything.
I wrestled with being depressed in high school, and I wrestled with it deeply in college, especially that first year. It’s been a while since then, and over these years I’ve grown to understand the root cause of feeling depressed came from thinking I didn’t have a passion. That no single thing got me fired up in a way that if I did not partake in that activity, I would feel like I was wasting time or effort or energy. No single thing gave me purpose or merit. When you’re surrounded by people who do have this, who have so figured out who they are and what their goals are and chase them, it’s hard to feel like your own goals or dreams carry any sort of weight. Watching people push themselves in the classroom and outside it, working toward becoming a doctor or a lawyer or anything equally admirable is hard when your goals are much, much smaller. It can make you feel like your passions aren’t passions or that you don’t hold passion or the capacity for it within your heart.
I steeled myself a lot, and still do, when it comes to thinking about dreams and goals. I think about and read about those people who are achieving big things. For so long, I compared myself (and to an extent, I still do that) and wondered why I was where I am age-wise, career-wise, goal-wise, and why I hadn’t done or seen or had more. Why I don’t have aspirations to be a library manager or director or in some sort of big leadership capacity within my professional organization. By 27, after a few years in the field, I thought I’d hit that point. But I haven’t, and I don’t know if I ever will.
I was that wildly impassioned 14-year-old I linked to back in the day; in revisiting old journals, the ones still easy to find on the internet with the right keywords or memory, I found myself talking about not bothering to go to college because I wanted to write. I revisit old journals from college and find myself talking about dropping out of college because I could write (my dream had been for so long to become a journalist and work for a paper because I was realistic in knowing I couldn’t make a living off writing poetry).
But then I look at the journals I kept in graduate school — probably the only time in my life I truly loathed school and everything related therein — and I found such satisfaction in writing about books. In talking about what did and didn’t work in writing. In sharing those books and my thoughts about those books with other people who’d have a light bulb go off. Who’d then read that book and tell me yes, it was great or that was terrible (sometimes those reactions are more satisfying). I found myself passionate about getting other people excited about things.
That’s part of why I’m a librarian, part of why I love working with teenagers — arguably the most passionate people around –, part of why I blog and talk about books, part of why I talk about writing as much as I do. I love getting people excited about the things that excite me. I love supporting people in their pursuit of their own passions and dreams and goals.
I’m lucky to have the opportunities in my life that I do, and I’m lucky to have a support system that not only encourages me in pursuing a passion that’s not top-caliber, not something that’ll be remembered a hundred years from now, not something that’ll bring me awards or accolades or, hell, any sort of financial stability. It is so hard sometimes not to stop and step back and worry about whether it amounts to anything of worth or value or whether it’s just spinning wheels. It’s hard not to wonder how many ways I’ve stalled out before I’ve had the chance to go somewhere further or deeper. Time ticks and you can’t always know whether what you’re pursuing has any meaning.
Passion makes you terribly vulnerable.
I try not to talk personal on this blog because, well, this is a book blog. I’m a non-biased, objective reviewer who aims to be critical and thoughtful. But over the last three years of doing this, I’ve had the opportunity to pursue a passion so deep and connect with other people who find themselves as impassioned as I am about getting other people excited about books and reading.
If the last week has been any indication — and I’m not just talking about this — I’ve found that being passionate means enduring a lot of judgment and criticism. That people are holding you to the same standards to which you’re holding those who you believe have a passion greater than your own. That people look at what it is that brings you value and meaning and wonder whether or not they themselves have that sort of feeling within them. Whether or not they’re exploring their own passions or feel as deeply about something that you do.
I let myself get really upset yesterday about the things people wrote about me. Let myself cry, then get angry. I let myself have that alone, by myself, on my couch. I still dread looking in my inbox whenever there is a new message. Still get a little worried when someone I don’t follow sends me a message on Twitter. Still find my heart racing whenever that post gets shared again somewhere.
The thing is though, I think my passion hit critical mass. My words? They were shared. People were listening, reacting, thinking. I shared and got a lot of other people really excited about things. I allowed the thing that got me going to be something that got other people going.
I acted.
Rereading the NYT article and rereading that post by an impassioned 14-year-old made me realize that what matters is pursuing what matters to you, regardless of what it means to someone else. I’m never going to be famous or rich. I’m never going to have a seven-figure book contract or star in a Hollywood blockbuster. I’m never going to be a doctor or a lawyer or a rocket scientist. But what I am and what I can be, I think, is so much more than a label or a position in management or in leadership by some name or title. I can share and support and love deeply and fiercely and find satisfaction in making the world just a little bit of a better place because of those things.
Words and actions are amazing things. When they’re used right, they ignite fires you could never imagine. I’ll never be extraordinary, but I can be satisfied with being ordinary — as long as I let the things I love be the center of what I do. Even if it hurts sometimes.
Janssen says
Kelly, I love this post so much. You really have an amazing gift for writing, and I'm astounded by how much passion you have for books and sharing them.
Susan Adrian says
I'm so happy that you're still going on, bb, in spite of all that has been thrown at you. Your passion is carrying you through.
And *I* think you're an extraordinary person. So there.
John Kirriemuir says
"I've found that being passionate means enduring a lot of judgment and criticism."
Point 8 on:
http://www.wordshore.com/?p=2493
Two points about the Annoyed Librarian.
1. It's anonymous for no legitimate reason e.g. fear of persecution from a regime. Therefore, it immediately has far less credibility than anything you write.
2. The only purpose of the Annoyed Librarian is to drive extra traffic, custom, to the LJ website and magazine. It's a purely commercial thing, not an intellectual thing.
Another way of looking at it. The Anonymous Annoyed Librarian deems what you have written important enough to sneer at and, in doing so, drive custom to LJ.
Keep writing. Keep blogging.
Jen Robinson says
"what matters is pursuing what matters to you, regardless of what it means to someone else" – YES! I'm reading your post, in conjunction with this one from The Nerdy Book Club: http://nerdybookclub.wordpress.com/2012/07/01/all-you-need-is-love/, and giving some real thought to what I want out of my blogging. Thanks for that! I think that you're extraordinary, too.
Paige says
Kelly, I want to say that I'm very impressed with how you've handled yourself in the wake of all these issues being thrown at you.
You've done a very nice job and been very honest, which is very impressive.
I love how much passion you have. It's obvious in all of your posts how much you love young adult books and ya lit. Your passion keeps you going.
So I commend you.
Lauren DeLaCruz says
I read your various posts about this and you were brutally honest about how you felt about something that you are very passionate about. And like anyone discussing something they are passionate about, you were completely on point with some things and maybe off base with others. But what does that matter? It's YOUR opinion! This is the internet, there will always be people who will want to destroy your best argument–if you had said 2+2=4 you would have gotten negative responses. I think your person reaction sounds totally normal and your posts have been honest and passionate. That's all that really matters. You might not be famous—but you certainly made an impact, and that is nothing to scoff at.
Lauren Monahan says
and you do such a good job of guiding the way YA is read today. There are many I know who look to your blog first to know about books, and to get excited about books. Pretty awesome to have that kind of influence in shaping a generation. So yeah, you'll have blowback sometimes. Par for the course. We live in a world where anything you say can and will be used against you in the court of public opinion, but if we let that fear silence us, keep us from speaking honestly, the world will be a far scarier place…as oh so many YA dystopian novels these days warn us against.
Kyle says
Kelly, thank you so much for writing and posting this. I think you and I are pretty alike (in more than just blogging/book stuff) and I can identify with so much that you said. I really trust and value your opinion on books/librarianship and I hate how some people have misinterpreted you in the last week. Keep on being passionate and awesome š
Sarah says
I told you this on Twitter, but I continue to be so impressed with how gracious you've been in the wake of all this stuff. You passion for reading culture and sharing that with others is infectious–thanks for continuing to share. š
Miss K says
Thank you for your continued honesty and passion.
R.J. Anderson says
This is a beautiful post. I'm a writer, not a librarian, but your comments about feeling like you didn't have that one single thing that made you passionate, and questioning yourself because of that, rang so very true to me. And so did your conclusion about finding your passion in getting other people excited about books. I've been finding that too, in my own way.
I read your original post about the ARCs at ALA and thought it well expressed, carefully reasoned and passionate without being inflammatory. I'm sorry that some people have taken it so wildly out of context and turned it into an excuse to attack you. But if it had to be, I'm (selfishly) glad this post came out of it, because our experiences of struggling with depression, feelings of inadequacy, and fears of being misunderstood are similar in many ways, and this post spoke to me at a time when I really needed it. So thank you.
angela says
I am a very new follower, and I think you are handling this with such grace and decorum. And if nothing else, I'm glad that the whole thing has helped you to see the value of your words and your passion š
admin says
Hearing this means a lot, and hearing you're a new follower means even MORE, so thank you!
Mandy (The Well-Read Wife) says
Kelly,
I started writing a comment and it was so long I went ahead and emailed it to you.
Just know that there are book bloggers out there that support you.
*hugs*
Lisa Schroeder says
Kelly, I admire your courage so much. I was on vacation for a lot of the time this whole thing was happening, but I've read some of the blog posts, and clearly this thing got bigger than you ever could have imagined, and I know it wasn't easy on you.
I think it's possible to have extraordinary moments in our ordinary lives. Be proud of this extraordinary moment where you made people sit up, take notice and THINK about their part in all of this. I don't know what the answer is, but I'm so glad people are thinking and talking about it. Thank you!!