I’m not going to write a lengthy post about the removal of Courtney Summers’s Some Girls Are as an optional — OPTIONAL — reading choice for students at West Ashley High School in Charleston, South Carolina. I’m going to instead direct you to Courtney’s impassioned discussion of this challenge to her book, along with Leila Roy’s commentary, and commentary from the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund.
I am a staunch advocate of intellectual freedom and have been since day one. I find it horrifying and small minded when one parent’s problem with material overrides the rights of every student to have access to material that not only impacts their lives, but that they would have the opportunity to discuss and engage with under the guide of adults who care about them and who want them to KNOW that they’re cared about.
To say this particular removal — one laden with missteps and subverting policies left and right — feels particularly brutal is an understatement.
So I’m doing something.
Thanks to a few phone calls, I was in touch with Andria Amaral at the Charleston County Library System about what could be done to get this book into the hands of the teens who want them. She feels as passionately about this as I do, as she said to me that she wants to stand at the door of the high school and pass this book out to kids. More copies of the book have been purchased for the library for their access, too.
Let’s do something together with our collective reader, intellectual freedom loving power, shall we? Can we get this book into the hands of kids of West Ashley who want it?
If you are willing to buy a copy of Summers’s Some Girls Are, I will send it down to Andria, who will get it into those kids hands for free.
Between now and August 17, I would love to see my house become overfilled with copies of this book. I will box them up and ship them all down to Andria that week, so she can get them into the hands of eager readers. Because Andria is also coordinating the efforts of the Cynthia Hurd memorial donations, it is easier for me to collect everything and send them down to her once, rather than have them trickle in to her.
Think this is a costly endeavor? Let me direct you to how you can participate, even if you’re short on funds.
Some Girls Are is currently $1.99 on Book Outlet, and What Goes Around, which is a bind-up of Summers’s Cracked Up To Be and Some Girls Are is $1. Right now, there are over 200 copies between the two of these books on Book Outlet. Let’s make them all disappear.
Can you spring $1 or $2 or $10 to get this book to these kids? It seems like a cheap way to tell these teenagers that their voices — their lives — really do matter.
You can, of course, send a copy from anywhere. I am not going to do anything but drop them into a big box to ship out.
If you want to take part, please drop your name and email in this form, and I will email you with my mailing address to make this happen. If you cannot participate yourself, please pass this along to anyone who might want to help out.
I removed the comments because they're not relevant to the issue at hand. This isn't about publicity — it's about a book being removed from teenagers by ONE parent without any proper policy being followed.
Yep! I'll be doing either that or flat rate, whichever is cheaper. Media mail now has tracking, so it's a lot safer than it was before July.
Just a note on shipping. If you go through the USPS and are only sending books you can send them Media Mail which is significantly cheaper than standard. It is the only class of mail that can be searched by the post office to make sure it is in fact all media, (books, lps, etc) but it should be perfect for this.
(Edited because I can't spell.)
This is the best idea. I'm happy to chip in.
Thank you!
I love what you are doing! I have a book blog as well and I posted about this very issue. I also linked back to your blog in case any of my readers want to participate. I hate censorship period.
Thank you so much. We're going to do right by these kids.
Thank you so much! We had a censorship issue come up at my middle school last spring, and I hate how it was handled. I was too shocked (and too overwhelmed with other issues in my life) to do anything about it after a couple of emails to my boss got me nowhere.
I dealt with two separate situations in working as a librarian, and in both cases, I fumed. This, though, was a whole other level, seeing how poorly the school followed their own policies and the voice of a single mother carried such power (and imagine being her kid — I feel for her!).
So the best way to respond? Let those kids know they have advocates like Andria in their very own community who care about them and want to be a part of enriching their lives.