El Deafo by Cece Bell
I don’t read a lot of nonfiction, but I do have a weakness for graphic memoirs. This one is superb – perfect for middle grade readers, with vibrant cartoon-like art (that reminds me a little of the Arthur cartoons) and a winning story. It’s a great read for deaf and hearing readers alike, giving mirrors to the former and windows to the latter. Even aside from that aspect of the book, it’s just a great story about growing up, about the vagaries of childhood friendships (I think we have each had or been a Laura, a Ginny, or a Martha) and the challenges we all face as we navigate adolescence. The way the story is presented is what elevates the book above some other memoirs. The representation of the kids as long-eared rabbits is a genius idea, and Cece’s imagination of herself as a superhero looking for a sidekick is such a great parallel to the real challenges she faces. What kid hasn’t dreamed up something like this?
The Red Shoes and Other Tales by Metaphrog
This is a really slim collection of three stories by Metaphrog, two of them retellings of Hans Christian Andersen fairy tales and one original. The titular story involves a girl named Karen who is given some very fancy red shoes and finds herself unable to stop dancing while wearing them. The other Andersen tale is The Little Match Girl, and the original story is called The Glass Case, which has a similar feel to the others (un-Disneyfied and somewhat gruesome, depressing, or both). I love the rich colors on the cover, but I found the art to be mostly uninspired. Faces aren’t terribly expressive (they’re either neutral or shocked) and the colors are much more muted on the inside. (To be fair, this was a review copy; it’s possible the look will change in the final version.) The re-tellings themselves are simply done, like the original fairy tales but lacking the depth I find simple language often gives. I’m always eager for fairy tale interpretations, but this one fell short.
This One Summer by Mariko and Jillian Tamaki
I have some prejudices when it comes to graphic novels, the biggest of which is I don’t really care for black and white art. This One Summer isn’t precisely black and white (it has a purplish/bluish tinge to it), but it basically is, and that’s the main reason I passed it by when it was first published. (I pretty much read every single full-color graphic novel First Second produces.) And then it won a Caldecott Honor and a Printz Honor, so I re-evaluated. The art really is very good. With black and white art, I always have to force myself to stop and peruse it rather than breezing by it, taking it in simply as a part of the story. Some of the spreads are even quite lovely, though I’d say Jillian Tamaki’s style is more interesting than beautiful. Her characters are expressive and diverse, and her backdrops are wonderfully detailed.
Books borrowed from my local library, except for The Red Shoes, which was provided by the publisher.