I will never grow tired of looking at and talking about YA book covers. Even more specifically, I love looking at redesigned covers and considering what it is that went into the thought process behind changing a book’s initial design into something different for its paperback release. Authors generally have little to no say in these redesigns, but rather, they often come about as a result of marketing direction changes or suggestions.
Let’s take a peek at seven upcoming YA book covers getting a new look in paperback. I’ve included a wide swath of titles here, showcasing some of the good, some of the bad, and some of the really questionable when it comes to YA hardcover-to-paperback redesigns.
Original hardcover designs are on the left, with the refreshed cover on the right.
I Have Lost My Way by Gayle Forman
After the splashy cover reveal for Forman’s latest YA book, it was surprising to me how little this book seemed to be buzzed about. I read it and while it wasn’t my favorite — I tend to find myself unable to really fall into her stories — I know she’s got a legion of fans and admirers, and given the elements present in this particular book, I anticipated more. Part of me wonders if the cover, which is pretty bland and forgettable in a sea of covers that make use of a font-driven design, made people bypass it. It looks like an adult book, rather than a YA book, and the title itself isn’t one that’s easy to remember. Working in favor of this cover, though, is that it looks nice on a screen; it’s easy to read and understand.
That last part is what made me do a triple take on the paperback cover: it doesn’t translate on screen. The white boarder, coupled with the text messaging along the bottom, made me think I was looking at a private text message someone was sending with a pretty confusing image on it. I think that it’s great to see a girl of color on the cover, but where is she walking? The book is set in New York City but it also looks like she’s walking through a dirt pit. Interestingly, the paperback makes the font for the title and the author name the same size, though my eye is more easily drawn to the author’s name because it’s a different color than the girl’s shirt.
Like the hardcover, aside from the confusing framing, the paperback isn’t especially memorable or distinct, either. I’ve seen this cover a few times and immediately thought of the Jessa Halbrook series (one of Saundra Mitchell‘s pen names).
I don’t love either cover but the hardcover is less confusing and less confused over all, with a more cohesive design. I Have Lost My Way comes out in paperback April 16.
Illegal by Bettina Restrepo
I’ve always wondered what happened to this book. I read it when it came out as a debut in early 2011, and it’s a book about a family that illegally crosses the Mexican border and heads to Houston for work, security, and pursuit of a better future. The book disappeared not long after it was published, which, given how much immigration has been a major topic prior to that time and after, surprised me. So I’m really pleased to see that it’ll be getting a paperback reissue on August 27.
There’s not a whole lot to say about the original cover except that it really captures the spirit of the story — as well as the spirit of YA book cover design in 2011. It’s a real model and, though we can’t see her face, she appears to be a girl of color. We have the city skyline in the background, with a title font that features a wire fence design within it.
The paperback design is a study of contemporary cover trends. We have a teen of color facing out, and it’s illustrated. The girl looks quite young in the image, which I like, as the book itself features not just a younger teen protagonist but also, it reads as younger YA. Maybe my favorite part of the redesign is one of the smaller pieces: the tag line above the title, “We are all immigrants.” Although the book cover and title certainly make it clear what the book is about in both covers, that small line really makes clear that this is a story for non Native Americans for non Native Americans.
I’m eager to pick up the book with a new forward from the author eight years after its original publication. The paperback redesign here is fresh and I’m suspecting it’ll ignite a lot of new interest.
Labyrinth Lost by Zoraida Cordova
Series redesigns always raise a lot of conversation. Readers who like their series to look cohesive often mention that they become frustrated with changes, while it becomes clear in some instances that the redesign of the series better reflects the way the series progresses or simply looks more interesting on shelves.
Which is why I’m fascinated by the cover changes that have happened with Zoraida Cordova’s Labyrinth Lost.
The hardcover design is one I really dig, in part because it plays homage to the lore within the book itself. The face painting, reminiscent of sugar skulls, is part of the fantasy in the book and something that Cordova digs into a little bit in her author’s note at the end of the book. It’s a very catchy cover, and it’s one that immediately speaks to the fantasy, the magic, and the traces of horror that the story holds. The font works for the title, though Zoraida’s name seems to get a bit buried on the cover. Shoved in between the author name and the title of the book is a blurb from Danielle Paige, but what’s fascinating in the design of those words is how her title and accolades actually take more real estate up on the cover than Zoraida’s name or the blurb itself. It almost feels like a well-thought tag line would be better there to really give a sense of the story’s content to readers.
The original paperback redesign in the center reminds me so much of the redesigned covers for Libba Bray’s “The Diviners” series. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing because I think the two series would make for great read alikes to one another, making the cover similarities work in favor of both. The font for the title remains the same in that redesign, but we’re given something new in terms of an image: the gate which the characters go through during the course of the story. There’s definitely a placement of this book into the fantasy/magical realism realm with the design. Zoraida’s name is a little bigger and more easy to spot on this design, and while the blurb from Paige appears again, it’s been better laid out so that it takes up less real estate on a book that’s not her own.
The final image is the second paperback redesign and it’s wildly different from the previous iterations. The title font is something different, but once again, Zoraida’s name is really small beneath it. However, big points in favor of the redesign are noting Zoraida’s own credentials (“award-winning author” below her name) and the fact that the blurb which took up so much real estate from the cover is now gone. Instead, we get a tag line: “The first lesson of being a Bruja: Magic always has a price.” It’s perfect and captures so much about the story’s genre, about the stakes, and about the cultural the story takes place in. The image and design itself don’t especially stand out to me but those textual elements are knockout.
All three of the covers do a good job, and all of them seem to be angling toward the same audience. It took me longer to pick up this book than I wished, and I wonder if the new look will prompt other readers who held off to give it a chance (it’s a fun read!).
Royals by Rachel Hawkins
Speaking of books I know are fun reads but that I haven’t picked up yet: Rachel Hawkins’s Royals came out last May and has been a book that I’ve again heard very little about. It’s a romantic comedy and the reviews have all mentioned how funny it is — something I believe, given that Hawkins is known for writing with humor. The original cover was very pink and blingy, which I think shows off a lot of what the contents are meant to do. They’re a little over the top but grounded in a real-life fantasy for readers. Hawkins’s name is big on the cover with a different tone of pink from both the background and from the note that she’s a New York Times bestselling author. The tag line is cute, too: “He’s no prince, but he sure is charming.” Readers who love royal-themed stories will know without question this book is for them.
That said, the redesign hits both the royal-themed story lovers and those who want a more straightforward YA romance read. First thing to note: there’s a title change. No longer is the book called Royals (which always made Lorde’s song get stuck in my head). It’s instead being renamed Prince Charming. True to charm, the font choice is cute, it’s a deep pink or red, depending on your resolution, and the “A” features a sweet little heart inside. The way that the two teens on the cover are standing and slightly overlapping the title is clever, as if they were there first before the title came toward them. It gives the cover some movement, which is important given how stark the two teens look being in sketched grayscale. We have another illustrated cover here, continuing to stay in line with the trend that’s been big in YA for a few years. Check out the chucks on the girl, too: it’s a nice nod to the fact that the heroine might be a little bit more quirky than she lets on.
Both covers are quite good. Readers who aren’t familiar with Hawkins likely would fall into two camps on this one: those who love their books royal-themed knowing that the hardcover is for them and those who think the redesign is super cute, feminine, and romantic and dive right in. Given that this is a series, though, the paperback ekes out slightly for me because the sequel takes a similar design approach. It hits shelves on March 5. Check out the sequel’s cover here, which adds itself to my ever-growing list of YA book covers featuring sunglasses.
Top Ten by Kate Cotugno
The hardcover for Top Ten is one I’m not a huge fan of, but that’s entirely for personal reasons. It’s a very 1990s style cover, which is way cooler among young people than it is with me. It is also super white in terms of the couples shown, with neon signs, chucks, and lights. The title is almost easy to miss here, since there’s so much going on, though Katie’s name is nice and easy to find. There’s no tagline and no blurb on this so it’s hard to say what the book is about, though the images suggest it’s a summer story about a group of friends.
I’ve mentioned before that illustrated covers are the thing in book cover design and have been since Eleanor & Park. I’m also not a huge fan of them because they tend to blend together so easily. That plays out in Top Ten, as I feel like I’ve seen this same design on about ten other YA books that hit shelves recently or will be hitting shelves soon. While the people are still all white-presenting, there is at least more array in body shape and size, as well as complexion and hair. It’s a bit more representative of today’s teens across a broader spectrum than the hardcover is. The title is much bigger and more obvious, and the font and color of it match the author’s name. Bonus: we get a tagline. “The unlikeliest of friends…or something more.” I like that it gives a sense of the story, but it also makes me a little confused when it comes to who is on the cover. Is it one couple that keeps looking different? Is it a lot of couples who are “something more?”
Neither of these covers really do it for me. Not having read the book yet, I can’t suggest which one is truer to story.
Top Ten comes out in paperback January 15.
Undead Girl Gang by Lily Anderson
Spoiler alert on this cover makeover: I love both of these covers very much and think both are excellent.
The hardcover for Anderson’s novel is really different. It takes a lot of the elements that are synonymous with today’s teens: enamel pins and denim jackets. This same trendy style is a throwback to the 90s and girl power culture, which fits in perfectly with the title and story itself. Without question, given the homage to new age beliefs (crystals and tarot cards) and the two zombie hands making the pinkie swear salute, this is clearly a book that’s a little bit horror, a little bit fun, and a whole lot about girls being good to other girls. The title being put into an enamel pin is clever, as is the way that Anderson’s name looks like it’s embroidered on the denim jacket.
The paperback cover also nails it. This is a book with a fat protagonist who has brown skin. That cover model is perfect, and not only is she perfect, but her stance and attitude speak volumes for what the tone of the book is. If you look closely, you’ll not only notice she’s wearing a denim jacket, but the pins that were on the original cover? They’re also on the jacket itself. If it weren’t for the fact that the pins on the hardcover were on one side of the jacket and on the opposite of the jacket in the paperback, you’d think this was simply a zoomed out take from the original design session. The title font is perfect here: it has a 90s clip art feel to it (and specifically, Word Art!). The font for Lily’s name is very modern though and is one I associate with contemporary cover trends, making this a nice mashup of today’s culture and nostalgic. The zombie hands? They’re just plain fun, and the tagline “We’re back, witches,” tells so much story in and of itself.
Both covers rock for different reasons. If pressed to pick one I like more? I’d say paperback, simply because it leans fully into girl power, feminism, and that cover model is just perfect. You can grab the paperback on May 14.
(Interesting to note that two redesigns are very pink covers. A trend to keep an eye on through 2019, maybe?)
You Bring the Distant Near by Mitali Perkins
Last, but not least, is one I’ll keep short and sweet. I love the original cover for Perkins’s book and I’m also really feeling the redesign for paperback. Not only does the redesign highlight that it’s a National Book Award nominee, but it also brings all of the elements that were inside the dancing woman on the hardcover and brings them to the outside. Look closely: the buildings. The grandeur. The feeling of connection to past and present. The dancers themselves. It still keeps the title the focus, but it also brings even more to the forefront. I’m also a big fan of the fact that the author name is even larger and more prominent in the redesign. My only critique is a tiny one, which is that the blurb on the bottom takes what is a well-thought out busy cover almost a little over the top in terms of putting a lot of things into a small space.
Perkins has a new book coming out this spring, too, and the cover design for that one has the same feeling as the new paperback redesign. You can peep Forward Me Back To You here.
So what do you think? Which covers are speaking to you? Which aren’t? Let’s talk in the comments!