I’ve read The Chocolate War before.
It was one of the first YA books I read in the YA Lit class I took in graduate school. Which means it’s a book Kimberly’s read, too — for those of you just tuning in, she and I met when we took that class.
Let me tell you a little bit about myself, circa September 2008: I had yet to actually work in a library with teenagers. I’d worked with teenagers before, but it was in a classroom setting for one summer. These were a very narrow group of teens. And this is nothing against them because they were wonderful to work with, but they all came from privilege, were all gifted, and they were all selected to participate in this series of advanced-level summer classes.
In other words, I’d yet to see the extremes of teens. I saw a pretty homogenous group with similar backgrounds.
My reading and reflection upon books and their audience very much was telling in my own experiences. (Isn’t it neat to see that in yourself, though? That’s one huge benefit of keeping track of your thoughts on books — you see your own growth and development as a reader and thinker and professional.)
To be fair, I don’t think I liked any of the books I read in the class I took. We read only a handful of classics, and the book that was most updated in our reading was The Geography Club. I did record all of my reactions to the books in Goodreads, so naturally, I have a nice review of The Chocolate War to share:
Not as controversial as I hoped, though I was disgusted by the characters discussing how they raped attractive girls with their eyes.
That’s all I had to say about Cormier’s book on my first read. I suspect my second read might merit a few more words, and I’m dying to know whether either of these statements still hold true. What did I want in terms of controversy in 2008? Will I see gender issues still? I’m actually pretty surprised to see that pop up in my review because when I thought about my reading of the book back then, gender wasn’t something I remembered at all. But it was apparently noteworthy!
Now, I should note that I did a couple of significant projects on banned and challenged books before I went to library school. My threshold for what I controversial, well. Let me say The Chocolate War may have been the most gritty (if that’s even the word I want) book I read to date at that point. So my perspective was not necessarily what it is today now that I’ve discovered dark contemporary books are totally my thing.
I’ve read so much more since 2008. I’ve also learned about reading and about the history of YA. I bring a lot more to the book and to the history of it now. Will this context and experience change my reading experience?
I guess we’ll find out at the end of the week.